PCS students in grades 9 and up are invited to participate in a range of after-school electives. Some examples include Urban Debate League, Student Senate, newspaper, cooking, drama, chess club, yoga club, community art, and urban gardening. These enrichment programs run from 3:30 pm to 5:00 pm Tuesday through Friday.
PCS also offers athletics at the High School level during the fall, winter, and spring seasons. Sports include soccer, basketball, baseball, softball, and outdoor track and field. Paul Cuffee School is a member of the RI Interscholastic League in Boys Basketball, Softball and Baseball.
There is no fee for sports or electives for students in grades 9 and above.